Sharing Cindy - S01 E44

Story 11 months ago

Sharing Cindy - S01 E44

Read Story: SEASON 1 EPISODE 44

The final thing I want to tell you about is when I finally got to fuck Sandy myself. The band had broken up as most of them had moved on to bigger and better things. Don unfortunately decided to focus more on his job and stopped playing. I am not sure what happened between he and Sandy, but after a short marriage, they got divorced and we didn’t see Don after that. Sandy of course, was constantly around and looking better than ever.

One night she showed up at our place with a new guy, Mark in tow. Mark seemed like a nice guy and we enjoyed hanging out with them. It was apparent that Sandy and him were at that stage of their relationship where they couldn’t keep their hands off each other. At one point during the night, I accidentally bumped into Cindy and spilled my drink all over the front of her sweater. She was bummed out about it but I said I would go get her another top. I went back to the bedroom and began going through her drawers looking for a top. I found just the right one.

Cindy has many sheer tops and usually she wears a lacy bra underneath. I knew she didn’t have one on under her sweater that night, so I grabbed a sheer blue top and headed back out to the living room. She saw what I had and started to protest. With a little convincing from me and both Sandy and Mark, we talked her into putting it on. Thank god for alcohol.

Once she had the top on, all of us could see her tits as plain as day. Mark really began to stare at them and Sandy got a little bit upset that he was focusing his attention on Cindy and not her. With that she said, “Here, let me give you something to stare at.” The next thing I know she is pulling her shirt off and standing there topless! Now it was me who was staring.

That seemed to break the ice, so to speak, and after that a lot of touching and grabbing was going on. Some how it ended up with the four of us naked and sprawled out on the floor. At one point during the fun, Sandy ended up in my arms and Cindy was across the room with Mark. I had been watching Sandy strut her cute little butt around me for years, and while we had had the chance to play and be naked around each other, I had never had the opportunity to actually fuck her. That was about to change.

I looked across the room and saw that Mark had actually positioned himself over Cindy and she was reaching between them to help guide him inside of her. I took that as the OK to do the same thing to Sandy. She looked up at me and asked if I was ready to feel her tight pussy wrapped around me. I told her I was. But first I wanted to taste her. I went down on her and licked her to a couple of really intense orgasms. She would make this cute little squeal whenever she came.

The time had finally come for me to actually fuck Sandy. I had her spread her legs and moved up between them. I couldn’t believe just how small of a girl she really was. As I began to push the head of my cock into her, it was apparent that not only was she a tiny girl outside, but inside as well. I do not have a monstrously huge cock, it is a couple inches above normal though, and right then I doubted it would even fit inside of her.

With a little patience and perseverance, I managed to finally sink deep inside of her. I swear that to this day, I have never felt anything quite as tight around my dick. He pussy was tighter than any other girls I had been in and even tighter than Cindy’s ass. She looked up at me and asked if I liked feeling that tight pussy? Oh hell yeah. It was incredible.

I would like to say I lasted for hours, but that would be a lie. A few minutes of stroking in and out of her were more than I could handle. It wasn’t long before I was ready to cum and asked where she wanted it. She told me to pull out and come on her tits. I waited until the last second and then pulled out and began to stroke it. Well, I at least tried to hit her boobs, but the force of my cum hit her square on the chin and covered her neck. What could I say? It was her tightness that had me so worked up.

I came down from my orgasm just as Cindy was hitting hers. We looked over and saw that she had climbed on top of Mark at some point and had him pinned down while she bounced on him. She really began to grind her clit hard against his pubic bone and in short order she was screaming out she was cumming. Sandy and I began clapping for the show.

We sat around naked with then for a while and were talking about some of our experiences when Sandy told Mark that she and Cindy had previously had sex together. He was super turned on by this and begged to see them together. The girls then fell into a comfortable embrace as Mark and I sat back and watched the show. Of course we both got hard again and we each were rewarded with a couple of fine blowjobs.

Sandy dated several different guys for a couple of years and finally found a great guy, Jimmy who she became serious with. Unfortunately her new guy was not into anything fun, so our sex fun came to an end with her. But up until she met Jimmy, I had the pleasure of having her share our bed on several different occasions. And on one weekend that Cindy was out of town, she sent Sandy over to keep me company for three days. I really miss that tight pussy and hope that someday I will get to experience it again.

To Be Continued...